Dai Ha 2302b3bc11
CI / contract (push) Successful in 50s
CI / build (push) Successful in 1m31s
#376: the too-fast failure stops asserting a cause it cannot know
A turn that settles inside MIN_TURN_NANOS is still reported FAILED. Only the claim
about WHY is withdrawn, and the pane is still carried.

Measured on fleet01 on 2026-09-08 UTC: an opencode member on mimo-v2.5-free answered
a real question in 1575ms, below the 2000ms floor. The daemon reported the turn as
failed with 'most likely a backend error before any work started'. The answer was
right there in the scrape. With no errorPattern configured — the live state on both
hosts, which both log as 'backend-error classification: off' — that sentence is a
guess, and a reader who believes it stops looking at the pane.

WHAT I REJECTED, because the next person will try it. A worker implemented the
ticket's first suggested direction: inspect the pane inside the floor and resolve a
COMPLETION when the text looks like a real reply. Its test for 'looks like a real
reply' was non-blank plus a '.', '!' or '?' anywhere in the text. That is unsafe
twice over. lastAssistantBlock falls back to the WHOLE pane when it finds no U+23FA
marker, so on a crash the candidate reply is the entire screen; and a crash pane
almost always contains a full stop, in a file path, a version or a hostname. I ran
that implementation against the new guard test and it resolved

    Error: connection reset while loading src/main/java/Foo.java v1.2.3

as a COMPLETION — expected: <FAILED> but was: <COMPLETION>. A loud wrong answer
became a silent one, which is the trade the ticket brief forbade.

The obvious repair does not work either. Requiring the U+23FA marker as positive
evidence would be safe, but that marker is Claude Code chrome and an opencode pane
never carries it — and an opencode member is what raised this ticket. There is no
reliable cross-backend marker for 'this is a real reply', so this path must not try
to judge one. That reasoning is now in the failTooFast javadoc.

Two guard tests. aPlausibleLookingReplyInsideTheFloorStillFails pins the safety
property against exactly the rejected approach; it passes today and fails against
that implementation, which is how it was verified rather than assumed.
theTooFastFailureDoesNotAssertACauseItCannotKnow pins the wording.

One existing test changed. aNonMatchInsideTheFloorStaysGenericAndNeverNotifiesTheSink
asserted the phrase 'too fast to be real work', which carried the withdrawn claim. It
now asserts what it was really guarding: the floor alone fails the turn, the reason
stays generic, the pane is carried, and the typed sink is never notified.

MIN_TURN_NANOS is unchanged at 2000ms. mvn clean install: 1441 tests, 0 failures.
2026-09-09 07:28:04 +07:00

claude-bridge

A subscription-safe bridge that lets a primary Claude Code (Opus 4.8, on Pro/Max) session drive a secondary Claude agent running a different model via its own ANTHROPIC_BASE_URL — without ever putting a proxy on the primary session.

Sibling of crush-bridge (which drives a headless Crush worker on GX10 DeepSeek). claude-bridge keeps the worker a real Claude Code process, so it inherits CLAUDE.md, hooks, skills, and MCP — just pointed at a cheaper/local model.

Leading approach — herdr-centric message server (fleetd)

A small always-on message server, fleetd, controls herdr (an agent multiplexer) over its Unix-socket API and exposes a clean 2-way messaging API as an MCP server that both the primary and the workers mount — one unified Claude setup and the sole communication gateway (REST/SSE stays for non-Claude clients; any broker is fleetd-internal, below the gateway). herdr owns the PTYs, multiplexing, persistence, and agent-status events; fleetd owns policy (subscription boundary, session lifecycle, status-gated delivery) and the client contract. A Claude member launches with ANTHROPIC_BASE_URL pointed at the gateway, https://llm.ltms.dev/anthropic, plus a bearer token; the lead stays env-clean and calls fleetd's MCP tools. See the wiki's 13 User Guide to run it.

flowchart LR
    OPUS["Opus — primary<br/>(Claude Code, env CLEAN)<br/>MCP client"]
    subgraph BD["fleetd — standalone daemon (not a claude process)"]
        SRV["SERVER face<br/>MCP · REST/SSE · policy"]
        CLI["CLIENT face<br/>status-gated injector · herdr socket"]
        SRV --> CLI
    end
    HERDR["herdr<br/>panes · agent-status"]
    W["worker claude pane<br/>ANTHROPIC_BASE_URL set<br/>MCP client"]
    M["llm.ltms.dev<br/>(the one gateway)"]

    OPUS -->|"MCP fleet_send (blocks)"| SRV
    W -.->|"MCP fleet_reply"| SRV
    CLI -->|"Unix socket<br/>send_text · events.subscribe"| HERDR
    HERDR -->|"drives PTY"| W
    W -->|"inference"| M

    classDef ext fill:#2b6cb0,stroke:#1a365d,color:#ffffff;
    classDef core fill:#2f855a,stroke:#22543d,color:#ffffff;
    class OPUS ext
    class SRV,CLI,HERDR core
  • Subscription boundary: the primary never sets ANTHROPIC_BASE_URL (stays on Pro/Max). Only the secondary process is off-subscription — and fleetd itself is a plain daemon (no Anthropic quota), so it may poll/subscribe freely.
  • One gateway (unified MCP setup): fleetd is the sole communication path for every Claude session. Primary and workers each mount it as an MCP server (one claude mcp add line, same on both) and talk over MCP tools — fleet_send / fleet_reply / fleet_status (with fleet_ask planned for the blocked-worker path). No Claude session ever addresses a broker, a peer, or the network directly; any queue is fleetd-internal. MCP tool I/O never sets ANTHROPIC_BASE_URL, so mounting the bridge is subscription-safe by construction. Tool naming: the tools are fleet_* (renamed from bridge_* in CB-622). The old bridge_* names were removed in CB-634 — only fleet_* answers now.
  • How the primary consumes a reply: a single blocking MCP call (fleet_send); fleetd holds it open until the worker calls fleet_reply or its turn hits agent_status=done, then returns the reply as the tool result. No cross-turn busy-poll, so no quota burn. SSE is an optional side-channel for humans/dashboards watching status.
  • Worker → primary rides fleetd's MCP rendezvous — the reply resolves the primary's blocking call (or, for detached work, fleetd injects the primary's idle pane when it's ready), so no keystroke-into-primary and no broker are involved, even single-host. The one exception: a split-host primary that isn't a herdr pane wakes via its own Stop-hook, which polls fleetd (never a broker). See the wiki for the two topologies.
  • Different model per process sidesteps Claude Code's lack of per-subagent provider routing — the worker isn't a subagent, it's its own configured process.
  • AgentAPI (coder/agentapi) is retained only as a swappable fallback injector behind the same interface. See the wiki for the full design, comparison, and rationale.

Docs

Full design, setup, and operations live in the wiki, vendored here as a submodule under wiki/:

git clone --recurse-submodules ssh://git@git.ltms.dev:2224/fleet/fleetd.git
# or, after a plain clone:
git submodule update --init

Edit docs in wiki/, then cd wiki && git commit && git push to publish them to the Gitea wiki.

Status

🟢 Implemented & dogfooded — the herdr-centric fleetd message server is built and in real use: an Opus primary delegates tasks to off-subscription workers that reply through the bridge (code reviews delegated this way have produced committed bug fixes). Selected as the primary approach 2026-07-11, superseding the AgentAPI plan (2026-07-08); AgentAPI retained as a fallback injector.

Shipped (Java 25 · Maven · 266 unit/acceptance tests green; the live-herdr and broker contract tests run separately via mvn test -Pcontract):

  • Core gateway — herdr socket client (contract-tested vs live 0.7.0); guard-checked worker spawn with ANTHROPIC_BASE_URL injected only into the worker's env; status-gated injector; blocking fleet_send with reply rendezvous; MCP server as a thin adapter over the REST core.
  • MCP tools — fleet_send / fleet_reply / fleet_status (messaging) and fleet_spawn / fleet_list / fleet_stop / fleet_profiles / fleet_poll (fleet). Caller identity is connection-based (loopback peer PID → herdr pane), so the same mount serves primary and workers.
  • Delivery reliability — completion fallback (a confirmed working→idle turn resolves a send); async fire-and-poll (beats the caller's MCP call timeout for long tasks); and failure detection for wedged (unknown), vanished, and never-ready workers so a send never hangs.
  • Fleet — multiple worker profiles, each with an independent base_url guard check; workers inherit the primary's working directory (never $HOME); a readiness gate holds delivery until a worker's Claude has connected the bridge MCP (no paste lost into its boot window).
  • Blocked-worker path — fleet_ask reverse rendezvous: a worker pauses its delegated turn to ask the primary and resumes the same turn with the answer (CB-205).
  • Session lifecycle — session manager with spawn/reuse/recycle, idle_ttl reaper, context_cap, and graceful drain on shutdown (CB-301/CB-303); per-worker git worktrees on their own branch with a config-parity overlay, so parallel implementers never stomp each other (CB-301-ext).
  • Reliable worker→primary delivery — a durable ReplyInbox (in-memory by default, AMQP/LavinMQ for cross-restart durability) holds a reply that arrives with no open send, and an active status-gated push loop nudges the primary to drain it (CB-307).
  • Pluggable peers — a PeerLauncher SPI with two in-tree adapters, claude-code and opencode, routed by a kind: discriminator (CB-401/CB-402).

Next (see the roadmap) — Stage 5 hardening (auth/TLS, /metrics, CI, service supervision, per-session authz + audit), then cross-host: CB-308 multi-host federation and CB-500 multi-tier coordination.

S
Description
No description provided
Readme 16 MiB
2026-08-10 15:58:06 +02:00
Languages
Java 94%
Shell 5.1%
Python 0.9%